Antonina's was recommended by out hotel front desk staff. We checked it out on Tripadvisor and decided to take a chance...
The atmosphere was that of a spiffed-up Pizza Hut, but with a friendlier staff and a somewhat nicer decor. For dinner my wife and I split an entree and shared a dessert. We both enjoyed a couple of glasses of wine from a limited, but good wine list.
Antonina's has good selection of "standard" Italian food. We went with something simple and straight forward, Rigatoni with Meat Sauce and a Caesar Salad. The servings were generous and tasty. (The Caesar and the pasta both could use more real parmigiano..!) The Tiramiso was okay, but next time I'll try something different.
Service was as prompt and professional as one could ask for in a family style Italian restaurant. Our waitress Summer was well informed and helpful. She added some personality to a nice evening.
Antonina's unfortunately has two (or three) wide-screen TV's going simultaneously, with the volume level set so that it maskst the background music. Summer accommodated our request to turn down the closest TV. We didn't ask her why restaurants need to have TV's..... (??)
All in all, we'd go there again, but we will check out some of the other Seneca Falls restaurants in the interim.
If you own or manage Antonina's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.