This place will cook the pizza just the way you order it. I asked for the bottom to be crispy and the outside crust to be burnt in places. They took it out once to show me and I asked them to put it back in. They did, nervously, and then showed it to me several minutes later. The crust looked perfect and it was crispy on the bottom and well done - not blackened - several places along the crust. The sauce is a little sharp but it toned down and balanced out by the mellow cheese, but neither the sauce or cheese has the true taste of a Manhattan or Bronx NY pizza. For starters, it needs a a little more oregano. Yes, I know you can add your own, but we are talking NY pizza here. The cheese is also good, but not NY stringy.
Bottom line: good pizza and they will bake to order but do not expect to relive your NY pizza experience here.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.