Like Skyline Chili, Graeter's was raved about by the fiance for years. Finally in town for the Flying Pig Marathon, I got to try it out.
I ordered 1 scoop caramel and 1 scoop Buckeye Blitz.
I thought it was really good, but it doesn't take the place of my favorite (Oberweis Dairy in Chicago). The fiance got the peanut butter chip and THAT was really good. They also have a pretzel cone which I didn't order, but tasted and it was really really good with the carmel ice cream.
My recommendation: Get a scoop of peanut butter chip in a cup and get the pretzel cone that you can dip into it.
Manager was also really friendly and gave recommendations.
If you own or manage Graeter's Ice Cream, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.