My wife & I recently saw Brighton Beach Memoirs and it was excellent. Fun, heart warming, touching. We go to many plays, but this is our first time eating Karlo's Bistro. My wife's pre-made chicken ceasar wrap was tasty, but soggy. My smoked turkey sandwich was just a turkey sandwich, nothing special for the pricey $9. On the website they show a wine bar w/actual wine glasses & chairs being used - - not sure where that is because the wine "bar" we saw used small plastic cups, and there are no chairs there. The real star of Playhouse in the Park are the shows - they are excellent, and there are many wonderful restaurants close to enjoy before and/or after.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.