Norey's is another of our go-to places on Broadway. Food is consistently good, and they have a great selection of beers on tap. And the desserts (especially the cakes, homemade by Norey herself) are excellent.
(I would also advise taking the negative reviews with a grain of salt- they seem be mostly from people having a fit because they have to take their hats off. (something that IS prominently displayed right by the door.))
If you own or manage Norey's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.