Hubby and I took a chance going here on a rare date night out. Having not been here for about 8 years as the food was terrible then we were very optimistic about the place seeming to be new. The inside was much brighter than I remembered and the staff is very friendly and welcoming. The food is another thing. Hubby ordered the prime rib which the outside was inedible and the rest he made edible with copious amounts of horseradish. My ribeye steak was just eh but I really would have loved some steak sauce to make it have any flavor. Overcooked and bland. They still have a salad bar which I think is silly in a supposed nicer steak place. With undercooked pasta salad in the mix as well. We also ordered crab stuffed mushrooms with no crab to be found. As a sides we got the twice baked potato which was ok and Mac n cheese. The Mac n cheese was just weird having some kind of peppers and corn in it! We were totally disappointed in this place and then after leaving and it hitting us, hey we just paid a ton of money and that sucked, we called the owner to let them know their shortcomings , but after waiting on hold for 10 solid minutes the owner would hardly let hubby get his comments in before rather rudely interrupting after each part hubby brought up. Won't be going back here for sure.
If you own or manage Horsemen Lodge Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.