I will NOT order or eat at the Fratelli's on Fourth Street again! I ordered my usual extra large meat lovers with mushrooms, onion and black olives added to the pizza. When I got the pizza home and opened the box, there was this strange odor emanating from the pizza. After careful inspection, I found that the black olives were rancid. I immediately called and reported this to the manager. I suggested that he go and taste the black olives. I asked that a new pizza be made without the black olives and I would return the bad one. I told the manager that the pizza was an extra large one. When I got back to the restaurant, several of the employees told me that they tasted the black olives and agreed with me that they were rancid. When my replacement pizza came out, it was only the large and not extra large. When I asked for a refund on the size difference, the manager was extremely rude and told me that it was my mistake and not his...besides, the difference was only $2. So, he refused to refund the difference. Rudeness from the manager...really?
If you own or manage Fratellis Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.