You can definitely tell that the ice cream is homemade, and there were some pretty unique flavors to the area like blackberry. We tried the mocha almond fudge and coconut almond joy. Personally the coconut almond joy was a bit too sweet but the mocha almond fudge was spot on! We also tried the homemade waffle cone--wasn't anything too spectacular so I probably wouldn't get it again if I came a second time. Overall it was a good visit! Has a very old school feel to the store, and they also have candy found back in the days!
If you own or manage Reimer's Candies and Gifts, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.