I didn't read the reviews of this place before I stayed there, and I'm glad I didn't. OK, it wasn't the Ritz, but it was clean enough for my VERY picky Mother-in-law. Yes, it's a bit rustic, but it served our needs very well.
If it had been my honeymoon, I might not have been happy, but for a nine-day stay with my family of 5 it was a very affordable "home base" used for sleeping, eating breakfast and washing up, and it worked fine. We had other friends staying in the area with whom we spent the days cruising around Santa Fe, and they paid many times what we did.
The Windsor Trail which is just above the place is a very cool hiking outing, too.