My husband and I stayed here during our honeymoon for two nights. We really enjoyed it. We got to the island with our car on the ferry. It was a very nice drive out to Lakedale. It was very quiet and there weren't a lot of people staying at the lodge, probably because it was the middle of winter. We stayed in the lodge and it was a wonderful room. Our one disappointment was the "jetted tub". This was mostly our fault because we assumed that meant a hot tub/jacuzzi and should have asked before booking.
Our room overlooked the lake as did the breakfast area. The breakfast was delicious, I have never had such good Greek yogurt before. We booked a package that included chocolates and champagne which was really nice, although the box of chocolates was tiny and I was expecting a little more.
All in all, a very pleasant stay. We would love to come back sometime, perhaps in the fall after tourist season but while it's still summer.