We were intrigued by the look of the place - with the fancy rotating display of the gelatos. We tried a few flavours and don't remember disliking any of them. My wife loved her chocolate gelato, but I'd highly recommend the pistachio gelato.
I'll be going back here if/when I'm in Tucson again.
If you own or manage Allegro il Gelato Naturale, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.