I really like this place- the decor is kitschy, the wait staff is friendly, and the owner is chatty and the food is good. I've eaten here so many times that I can't list all the items I've tried- I usually go for a gyros plate, which is hard to find fault with. We order the chicken or calamari quite often as well- both great. I also really enjoy their Moussaka. I've tried all the appetizers and they are all very good. The taramosalata is good, quite fishy, but I suppose that's just what it is. I have found recently though that some of the menu items have been really, really garlicky. I like garlic, but this is a bit over the top. Also, I've noticed that the prices are going up...and up....this wasn't the cheapest place to eat in the first place. I hope they stay put!
You will find that you end up taking a good portion of your food home as the servings are massive! I personally like this because I know I'm going to get two good meals out of what I order.
If you ask the owner, he'll even come up with a menu for your table and just bring dishes he thinks you should try- we do this and always enjoy it.
If you own or manage It's Greek to Me, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.