This restaurant is hidden in the back of a strip mall in Catalina on north Oracle Road. We had gone there a couple of months ago for a large group dinner where the food was served family style and really enjoyed it so we decided to give it a try on our own. We were not disappointed.
We both ordered the gyros plate which came with a greek salad and pita bread. The salad was very fresh and tasty, the pita was fresh and warm, the meat was very good and the tzatziki sauce was the perfect accompaniment. Portions were very generous - my wife took home about half of her meat and pita bread.
The service was also excellent - attentive but not intrusive, and very friendly. After dinner, our server showed up with a dessert to share, saying it was on the house because the owner thought it had take too long for us to get our food do to a mix-up in the kitchen. That was really news to us since our food had come out within a reasonable time, but it's just indicative of how the owner goes the extra mile to make sure his guests are satisfied. We'll definitely be back!
If you own or manage It's Greek to Me, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.