This place has a great location--quick to get to restaurants, beaches, and other attractions. However, it is not in a crowded, high-traffic area, which makes it peaceful and it feels safe.
For the price, you get a great room. Ours was impeccably clean and comfortable. Great plumbing, great A/C and good sized refrigerator. We slept better in the bed than we do in ours at home.
The staff is also incredibly friendly. My husband went down to see what time the complimentary breakfast ended (9am) and it was already after 9, but the employee at the front desk assured him that if we hurried back, they wouldn't take it away until we ate.
We chose this place because of the price and the reviews. If you are on a budget and/or plan to spend most of your time out and about, I sincerely doubt you would be disappointed in choosing Best Western on the Island. Literally the only thing I would change is the size of the pillows, which are square rather than round, but this is negligible and hardly impacted our stay.
It says everything that the staff at this location hand you a printout asking you to review them on this site. They take pride in their facility and the high level of customer service they offer and they welcome your business. In a time when service seems to decline with every passing day, that means everything. I would highly recommend this hotel, and in fact, I already have.