My husband and I just spent a wonderful relaxing week at the Four Seasons Maui. The level of service is extraordinary. Every staff member bends over backwards to make sure that you have an incredible experience. The pool is small and could probably do with out the big fountain that obstructs the center of the pool, but really the beach is so beautiful and the water is so warm and calm that I was happy to swim in the ocean rather than the pool.
My only complaint is the "partial mountain view room" at $500+ a night which is actually a "full parking lot view" There are several rooms across the back of the hotel that have this view. The bellboy told us that the original design showed these rooms as the entrance to the hotel. Guests should not be put in these rooms perhaps they could be turned into storage rooms. This was the first vacation in which we spent absolutely no time on our balcony.
I would return in a heartbeat!!