The ambiance and wait staff are great, and the menu is varied. We chatted with others waiting for tables and all mentioned they'd tried many different burgers and liked them all. But for a restaurant who's name wants to "say it all", they missed the mark. Two of the 4 of us moved our doneless level from medium to medium rare when ordering, yet we got one on the medium-well side (just a hit of pink) and the other even less pink. Our waiter said "yeah, some times they come out the way you ordered, and other nights not so well". Good, inexpensive beer selection. Not all beef, they have turkey, lamb, etc. We didn't find it too loud, conversation was easy.
If you own or manage Five Star Burgers, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.