We go here all the time. Best pizza in Omaha in my opinion. The cheese bread with romano cheese is so good but make sure you ask for fresh bread because otherwise they will take it out of a warmer. It is still good but the fresh is out of this world good. The pizza is a thinner to medium thickness, chewier crust. The sauce is really good, not sweet or spicy really. Usually lots of cheese and very high quality meat on the pizza. I like the atmosphere. It has a full bar. It is a hole-in-the-wall that lots of local families who have lived in Omaha for years frequent regularly. It is not fancy by any means. Prices are not cheap but not high either. It is unique but traditional pizza and not really comparable to any other pizza in Omaha. The service is usually pretty good. Sam, the hostess is a former student of mine and is really friendly! The girls at the register are nice too. You order at the counter and they call your number to go back up to the counter when your food is ready. Of the dozens and dozens of times I have been here, I have probably only had less than amazing food once or twice (too little cheese, slightly old bread). It is usually awesome and I highly recommend you try it and see if it is your type of pizza since we all have different taste in pizza.
If you own or manage Johnny Sortino's Pizza Parlor, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.