While in town with family, we dined on a Friday night. Make a reservation as it is a must. The restaurant is not very big. It has lots of rich dark wood furnishings. Tables are spaced enough to have a romantic dinner or to dine with a group and not feel the volume is too loud for other diners. The appetizer menu is great. If you are a Vodka drinker and enjoy oysters, ordering the 4 oyster vodka shooters are a must. You get 4 local shots of vodka and 4 different oysters with a piece of paper describing them. Very good! We ordered most of the appetizers and never ordered dinners. Steak tips were very good. Clam chowder was nice and thick. Local steamed muscles were a little strong smelling so we sent them back and they were removed from the check. Calamari was delicious, lobster ravioli was perfect. Portions were shareable but on the small side if you are super hungry. Service was good. Only complaint was the online menu from restaurant website is much larger in selection from what is actually presented table side. Probably one of the reasons we did not order any main courses.
If you own or manage The Brooklyn Seafood Steak & Oyster House, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.