We live here, and went for our anniversary. We requested an outside table and got one right next to the wall overlooking the ocean. Downside was the weather was very cloudy so there was no sunset. Food was very good. We had a catch of the day which was Ahi, cajun style, which was $37, nice size portion and tasty. Also the seafood linguine, which was tasty and good size, although the sauce was pretty thin. Keep some of the bread to soak up the broth! Service was excellent, although it was not very full especially for a Saturday. Cheese flatbread for appetizer was also good, but small for the price ($8).
If you own or manage Anthony's By the Sea, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.