We were in Plains for the two weeks prior to Christmas and sadly the restaurant was preparing to close for the holidays - so cut back on food preparation. The chicken salad sandwich was excellent, but then they ran out. The chicken sandwich was excellent, but then they ran out. The grilled cheese is very light on cheese, but otherwise ok. The fries are also excellent. The staff was consistently nice and friendly. It's worth eating here, just try to avoid the holidays. As others have indicated, the prices are very reasonable.
If you own or manage Old Bank Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.