It was very clean and comfy, in a walkable location. Staff was friendly.
There was usually only one valet working at a time, so we usually had to wait to drop off or retrieve our car. Not what I expected for the extra per-day price. The front desk was one floor up. Not a problem, but it felt unwelcoming and confusing at first not to have someone greet guests on the ground floor.
The room was nice. Thermostat was easy to control. Blackout curtains were great. Wi-fi was free and worked well. The barn-style sliding door to the bathroom was a nice decorative touch, but very impractical. It didn't lock, it rolled back open behind you sometimes, and allowed too much sound to escape. Not the best idea in terms of privacy.
Although there were no real problems outside of valet waits, the three star review is just because we expected a bit more for the price.