When I go to a restaurant, I'm looking for good food, good value, good service and good atmosphere. When I go to a gelato place, I want good gelato. I'm not planning to sit around for an hour or two... don't care too much about atmosphere and service - I want good gelato.
This place has good gelato. The owner clearly prides himself on his creations. They are free with tasting scoops, so there is no reason to be disatisfied with your selection. They will also give you two varieties in a cup if you ask - even three in the larger size. The prices are actually quite low for homemade gelato compared with other places around the US.
The owner is an interesting guy. He has strong opinions - he won't push them on you, but if you engage him he will respond with lively conversation if there are no customers waiting. Some folks might find his personality a little strong, but we enjoyed our talks with him.
If you own or manage Alotta Gelato, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.