I give this about 3.5 stars. I live pretty close to Jimmy's and never really have a problem getting a table or a seat at the bar. Whenever I seem to go (5+ times in three months) I've never seen it full. I have had hit or miss service here. Most of the times it is very good, but a few times it has been a little slow. The pizza is very good.
We always have to ask to put major sports games on (Red Sox, Celtics, Bruins), there's always something else on TV.
Good place, not great. A little more casual than the other places in Washington Square, but still leaves a little to be desired. Not quite a sports bar, not quite a fancy bar, just caught in the middle.
If you own or manage Jimmy's Bar & Oven, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.