I celebrated my birthday at Orsay and this was my choice about my perennial birthday favorite, Bistro Aix. My dinner companions had earlier groaned...."Aix, do we have to go back there again?" So Orsay it was. Not at all disappointed. Great pace of service, nice wine list and great variety of menu. It reminded me a lot of Balthazar in NYC, without the bakery. We even had the seafood plateau, which is not to be missed. I think my old favorite has now been trumped!