The place is small and dirty looking, the owner is gruff and borderline rude, but the guy who makes the pizza is super nice and their upside down "red top" pizza is the best I've ever had. The sauce is really good and the crust is very tasty. Decent size slices too. When they don't have the red top available I walk around the corner to Top Tomato instead. I've tried the pepperoni and the cheese but both are too greasy for my liking.
If you own or manage NYPD Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.