With all the competition in the ice cream market, including the super market big guys (Ben and Jerry's), small independent shops need to crank it up to compete. In fact, I would bet it is made off site and by some mega manufacture, which can also be ok. Unfortunately this makes for 'ok' ice cream which, while it is good, it is not great. Yes, the baked goods, specifically the pies, looked delicious. I didn't try the sandwiches or anything else. I think if you have the words "Ice Cream" in the name of your restaurant, it should be great ice cream.
If you own or manage More Than Just Ice Cream, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.