I have lived on Whidbey for 6 years and I hadn't heard about this gem. Went there recently and everything we had was cooked to perfection.. My date had the beef and it was fabulous flavor was wonderful. I had the special of scallops, sautéed kale, mushrooms and pasta, excellent preparation. A little spendy but at least the meal was good. Right now best restaurant on Whidbey... looking forward to going back. Service was a tentative a little over zealous but settled down once they figured we weren't in any hurry.
If you own or manage Oystercatcher, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.