Our B&B innkeeper suggested this place...and judging by the packed parking lot, this was definitely the place to eat fresh fish with the locals. My husband and I chose the fish platter for 2, and added on a bowl of crab bisque. The crab bisque was very good, great taste. The fish platter had deviled crab, fried oysters, fried clam strips, and we chose to have the rest grilled - shrimp, scallops and a white fish. Service was a tad slow - but they were packed to overflow on a Tuesday night. Our server, the "old lady", was friendly and helpful; she was running her legs off trying to keep all the food coming out. There was ample food for 3 on this platter and I felt bad that we couldn't finish it all.
If you own or manage St Marys Seafood & More, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.