I paid a visit to this diner on my third visit to New York City, and I have no idea why I hadn't visited this diner before. I have been to Blooms Delicatessen a couple of doors down a couple of times which I wasn't very impressed with, so we decided to give Scotty's a try, and it was amazing. I was initially drawn in by the good reviews on TripAdvisor (always a good thing). Originally from England, I love the traditional American diners and this fits the bill. Some would say it was a bit dated but I think it has character - the waiters were very friendly, and constantly topped your coffee up every time they walked past if you wanted them to which is great value at $1.25. The food was very good, especially the bagels.
I will definitely be paying another visit if I am in the area and I suggest other people to as it is just down the road from Grand Central Terminal. You will not be disappointed.
If you own or manage Scotty's Diner, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.