While in town for a wedding we stayed in The Library Suite..When we were escorted to our suite ..through the elegant hallway a treat to the eye while classical music was softly playing as we made our way up the stairway past the stained glass lit walls. The suite was covered with floor to ceiling books, and a library ladder,a sky light, a bottle of wine, and all kinds of edible treats.
Anything you might need has been thought of.
The Inn was in a great location close to some great restaurants, shops, movie theaters...
The staff were all incredibly helpful and welcoming!! Our stay at Inn NYC
was truly memorable. We highly reccomend this beautiful,luxorious hotel!

Can't say enough good things about this place !
We stayed in the Vermont suite which was situated on two levels, joined by a spiral staircase - The whole place was just so welcoming and comfortable.
The location was also great - close enough to everything you want to visit in this great city but far enough off the 'beaten track' to be quite and homely. Being situated in the upper west side, we also found it really convienient for great restaurants in easy walking distance!
Inside, as mentioned, was really welcoming and comfortable - enough complimentary snacks and drinks as you could want to make yourself feel right at home and full of all the guides and information you will ever need to finalise or inspire your choice of things to do!
In all, I think I can best describe it as like staying in a friends house in one of the greatest cities in the world - it doesn't get much better!
It truly deserves it's 'Excellent' rating!

This is a very interesting place to stay but definitely different and may not suit everyone. It is comfortable and everyone is very friendly and I really enjoyed staying here but left then for a 5 star on Madison and when I go back, I will probably pick the Madison Avenue hotel.

Just returned from my second stay. My husband and I work in the city and like to occasionally get theater tickets and stay the weekend. This is absolutely my favorite place to stay. Ruth and Elyn make you feel like your visiting a friends and they have given you your own suite and alot of privacy.
On my first visit there was a bottle of white wine in the refrigerator (not a fan of white) this time when making my reservations I asked if they could possibly leave red. On my arrival there was a bottle of Syrah on the counter waiting for me (I LOVE THIS PLACE).
I can't really say which suite was my favorite. They were both special in differant ways.
The VERMONT SUITE - very private - you have your own entrance - the bedroom being down a spiral staircase is great - I really liked the two levels.
The OPERA SUITE - Baby grand piano (my husband played a bit) - Jacuzzi tub in bath which I took advantage of - best part was the private terrace - lucky for us the weather was beautiful so we sat outside in the late afternoon having wine, cheese, crackers and fruit.
They are both beautiful. I will definately be back, I have two more suites to try. I just wish there wasn't an extra charge for a 1 night booking, even though I absolutely understand why that is the policy.
Hope to be back soon.