We could not have asked for a better room or location. We were looking for an old-fashioned, charming, spacious, comfortable but reasonably priced place to stay in the coolest part of the city and the Marcucci Apartment delivered on all counts.

It was a pleasant surprise to wake up to the smell of cupcakes from the well-known Magnolia Bakery two doors away, and we also made full use of the fashionable and moderately priced restaurants/bistros in the Greenwich Village/Meatpacking District vicinity.

We would certainly stay again but would perhaps hesitate before recommending it to our friends - we don't want everyone going there!

Stayed here for two nights. A fabulous place - clean, comfortable and well appointed. Convenient location, close to great places to eat - and very safe neighbourood. A great rate for New York!

Room spotlesslessly clean. Hosts congenial and very helpful.

Would definitely stay here again.

We stayed in the Leonardo Junior Suite. We are generally in accord with previous very positive reviews, but had expected two things to be different.

First, although there is a fridge and a coffee maker, there are no dishes or cutlery, so this is not a place to have take-out or delivered meals, cook food, or even to have breakfast. There was no microwave as descibed on West Eleventh's website.

Also, the website description of the "extra-thick plush mattress" was not really accurate either. When I first lay down on our mattress my surprised reaction was "ouch! this is really firm and unpadded." Quite a contrast with the desciption I read. Still, it was better to sleep on than a sagging worn out mattress. (Just misleading.)

Stayed recently in West Eleventh for 3 nights. My favorite area in NYC.....in the Village, but on one of its quieter streets. A location for people who want to share being in a true New York neighborhood. Turn right or left out the front door and you've found Manhattan living at its best. My room (large, high ceilings, with bed and kitchen alcoves) was at the back, overlooking garden areas which will be increasingly handsome with warmer weather. I could never have imagined such a quiet night's sleep in NYC. Try also to chat with the owners who live on site......very pleasant and knowledgeable about the area, which they love.