Walked from Helmsley Hotel and we were so glad we did. We arrived at 5:30 and there was hardly anyone there so we were a bit nervous. But it filled up as we had dinner. Definitely an older restaurant. The curtains and pictures all hanging in a row all very "old school." But all in all the place was delightful. The service was wonderful. Waiters were attentive and friendly. And the food was amazing. The caesar salad was delicious but I must admit I was disaapointed in the lettuce. Looked like iceberg. I would still get it again. Very tasty!
I had the veal marsala. Loved it. We ordered broccoli rabe and potatoes. Both wonderful. We eat a lot of Italian food and the food here is really delicious. The portions were large so we had too much food (we probably shouldn't have ordered the potatoes). We had to leave it since we had no refrigerator in the room :-( I would definitely go back if I was in this part of the city. We were impressed.
If you own or manage Pietro's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.