If you are looking for a great Italian restaurant with delicious food, great service, friendly staff, nice atmosphere and reasonable prices, right in midtown Manhattan's Theater District, this is the place!! I called the restaurant to make a last minute reservation for two people on a Thursday night at 8:30pm, and the host said, "Come right over. We have a table and we can seat you right away". When we arrived, the restaurant was busy, but the staff had held a table for two for us, and we were seated right away, just as they had promised.
We ordered their signature dish - the black, squid ink pasta with seafood, and it was amazing. We also ordered the Antipasto Classico for 2 people, which was a hot antipasto dish with seafood and eggplant in a delicious marinara cream sauce. The shrimp in that dish was the best shrimp that I have had in a long while. The bread that was placed on the table is freshly baked and served warm with butter and also olive oil and balsamic vinegar. Our waiter suggested the Tiramisu for dessert, which was fantastic. I suggest that you save room for dessert, as it is well worth it!
This is my new favorite Italian restaurant in NYC. The dishes were a good size, so we shared our entree and were completely "full". Our dinner tab with 3 drinks - 2 glasses of wine and one martini - and tip was just shy of $100! That is quite a deal for a great dinner in the Theater District for two people. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone - business, date night, out with friends or out with family.
If you own or manage Trattoria Trecolori, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.