The chef's special bread was very good
The steak was okay/good - I take part of the blame for my food not being GREAT I guess- I made a mistake of asking for Bearnaise sauce instead of whatever sauce came with the Filet (I had never heard of it) and then my food was pretty dry. We are carnivores so while we enjoyed the meal - it wasn't the best steakhouse we had never been to on vacation, or compared to the places in Boston we frequent.
I also think for the price the atmosphere could have been a little swankier. But I know that's part of NY restaurants things are pretty small.
If you own or manage Old Homestead Steakhouse, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.