My family and I enjoyed a nice dinner here around 8pm on a week night, no reservation was made. I ordered the Prix Fixe menu that was priced at around $32.00 and came with French onion soup, beef medallions, whipped potatoes, and a chocolate raspberry cake. Every thing I ordered was absolutely delicious! What I enjoyed most was the French onion soup, its by far the best soup I have ever had. Very crispy baguette, great portion of melted cheese, and well seasoned broth. Another fantastic part of my meal was that the "medallions" were not your typical small pieces of meat you sometimes see, these medallions were about 3 ounces each and it came with 3 of them. The steak was perfectly cooked and seasoned, dessert was very tasty, and the service was great. I loved the classic yet sophisticated atmosphere of the restaurant and enjoyed the dim lighting. I would highly recommend Rosie O' Grady's for a romantic dinner or a dinner with family and friends. It would also be safe to make a reservation on weekends as with most places in NYC, enjoy!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.