Tourist trap, looks cute 50s diner style, but $23 for a hot dog with kraut, or for a reuben with a dab of cole slaw on the side? Tables cramped, ambience loud. Unable to help our gluten-free diner very much. Will not split checks, but you can use multiple forms of payment. Some tables too close to door that blows cold wind every time it opens. The food was very well prepared but at triple the price you would expect even in NYC. I would never return.
If you own or manage Brooklyn Diner, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.