My Husband and I heard quite a few good things about John's. So we decided to stop by while on our trip. When we got there we were promptly sat and got our drink orders in. Our waitress wasn't rude by any means, but she just wasn't very personable. We ordered the Garlic Rolls for an appetizer and those were pretty darn good. Then we got our Pizza, we ordered a "Classic" pizza.
Now after reading reviews and such, I was expecting this heavenly delicious New York pizza and...it wasn't what I expected. It wasn't any better than the pizza we get back home in Michigan at our local Jets, especially for the price.
I guess just the disappointment on top of the not so personable staff made it not the best experience.
However I will say, the place looks really cool. It has two floors, the top floor overlooks the main floor like a balcony, and theres a really neat large mural on the main wall.
If you own or manage John's Pizzeria - Times Square, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.