Every time we visit New York city, I see this restaurant and I have wanted to eat here. The ambience is wonderful and it truly is a Irish pub with wonderful food. The service was fast and the waitress was very attentive. I would come here alone for the music. (60's)
I had bought a gift certificate through Restaurant.com and that was the main reason for our group of four to go into OldCastle Pub & Restaurant on December 13, 2012.
We travel to New York City at least once or twice a year and I have bought a lot of Restaurant.com gift certificates for New York City.
However we learned that although the website for Restaurant.Com still shows my gift certificate valid, I was told at Oldcastle that they have not accepted the Restaurant.com gift certificates for over a year.
Even though we spent more money on our food than we should have because we were trying to buy the amount on the gift certificate, the manager gave us a 10 percent discount. And we did find an exceptional place to eat and we will return again.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.