We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox. Mac: Safari.
Free Newsletter

Interested in New York City?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for New York City each week.

Explore other New York City resources:

Croton Reservoir Tavern: Restaurant Reviews


TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:
  • A summary score based on quality, quantity and age of traveler ratings.
 5 of 5 stars 6 ratings
6 ratings
5.0 of 5 stars
1
4.0 of 5 stars
4
3.0 of 5 stars
1
2.0 of 5 stars
0
1.0 of 5 stars
0
TripAdvisor Popularity Index:
  • Measures overall traveler satisfaction based on ratings, reviews and other sources.
#1,062 of 6,756 restaurants in New York City
Reserve with Open Table
Show Restaurant DetailsHide Restaurant Details
  • Cuisines: American
  • Neighborhood: Times Square/Theater District
  • Address: 108 W 40th St, New York City, NY 10018
  • Tel:  (212) 997-6835

Traveler Reviews

[ Date ] [ Rating ]
“A nice surprise of a restaurant!”

Croton Reservoir Tavern

Save Review
4 of 5 stars
148jules 9 contributions
Vancouver, BC
Oct 2, 2006
1/1 found this review helpful

I found this restaurant on opentable and took a stab at it. When you go between 4-7pm do ask for the pre-theatre menu which is a great deal at $30 for 3 courses! The entrees are the same as the a la carte menu and typically "American" sized portions i.e. huge! Grilled skirt steak absolutely delicious. Simply grilled salmon a bit overdone but very tasty and served with a lobster hash!
Appetizers of green salad and daily soup were also fairly large; the mozzarella and tomato was simply that: one slice of each :( and the NY cheesecake for dessert superb.
As this is a tavern/bar with TVs set on sports channel it must get pretty loud on sports nights. However the night we were there it was reasonably calm and half full.
A great find!

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
Write Your Own Restaurant Review
Been to Croton Reservoir Tavern? Share your experiences!
Write a Review
Add Photos
Add Videos

Do You Own Croton Reservoir Tavern?

TripAdvisor has free and easy resources to help you enhance your listing and promote your property.

  • Start Here - Visit Your Owner's Page
  • Add Photo
  • Add Video

Croton Reservoir Tavern Address

108 W 40th St, New York City, NY 10018
Tel: (212) 997-6835
* Restaurant price information is based on meal cost per person, excluding drinks, tax and tip.