We just returned from a visit to NYC with our travel group of six. We love fine dining and research our choices wherever we travel. This was hands down the best meal our entire group has ever had! From the service, ambience, choices of wines and of course the food, we had absolutely no complaints! We each had different entrees and sampled one another's, with no consensus as to the best!! They were all wonderful!! All of the appetizers were similarly fantastic, and we enjoyed several desserts and wines! It is a dining experience, to be savored and enjoyed over a long and leisurely evening. The prix fixe menu is absolutely reasonable for all that you get. It is not a terribly large place but we didn't feel other diners were too close or too loud, although the restaurant was full. Perhaps we bothered other diners as we had a wonderful time but again our servers and the maitre' de made us feel like we were the only group in the restaurant! . This is a wonderful area for restaurants and bars and we have visited others over the years but none compare to scalini fedeli! Kudos to chef Michael Cetrulo for creating the perfect Italian dining experience in the big apple!