The moment we arrived we were greeted warmly by the doorman and treated like dear old friends. He and every other staff member remembered and used our names each and every time they saw us. The food in the spledid Asiate was 5 Star and beautifully and lovingly presented. Our room was wonderfully appointed with every luxury convenience one could or would expect. This one place that truly seems to anticipate your every need.

The guest rooms all start on the 40th floor of the high rise building. Thus, each room has a wonderful view of either Central Park or the Hudson River.

Can't wait to go back!

A truly fantastic hotel for service, ambiance/design, location and overall quality. It is my favorite amongst all of the hotels I've stayed at in NY (both Ritz Carltons, Pierre, St. Regis, Four Seasons plus many others). The design aesthetic is relatively modern with MO's typical Asian themes. Service is impeccable. The staff must have be both selected and trained with care. The amount of small talk the staff can conjure up is quite amazing -- they somehow manage to make it feel very genuine as opposed to patronizing.

Pros:
* Design: modern with Asian influences. It feels sleek and modern, and much less "stuffy" than many of the other high-end NY properties.
* Location: Columbus Circle is fantastic if you like going out to the park, and it is attached to the Shops at Columbus Circle for easy access to shopping and dining.
* Rooms: very high quality finishings, spacious bathroom
* Views: great views of the park and/or river, particularly from higher floors
* Gym: very high-end equipment, great service, nice selection of complimentary refreshments
* Catering: fantastic food in the ballroom and conference area
* Food: Great cocktails and food in the bar and restaurant area

Cons:
* Conference staff: while attending a conference I noticed the staff that does catering and such for the conference center/ballroom seemed to have significantly less training. A simple complaint is that they were very noisy and always yelling back and forth, even when we opened the door of our room and asked them to keep quiet.
* Expensive: there is no doubt that the hotel is expensive, but the MO NYC certainly strives to make it worth the expense.

this is one of the best hotels in NYC. great experience. prices accordingly...

How can a "5" star hotel not have a bar that actually opens 7 days a week when you pay around 1500 US dollars a night you would expect a bar in the hotel that opens 7 days a week. It actually closes on Sunday and Monday you then have to wait in line for a table in the lounge / foyer with any other people that we just walk in off the street and who are not guests. Even worse you you go and stay over new year 2011 and then find on new years the bar closed, so you then get told there is a 1 hour wait to sit in the lounge amazing. Considering I stay at the Oriental Bangkok and also Hong Kong I just wonder if the New York Oriental is actually part of the group.

Philip Webb