The setting is beautiful and impressive on the corner of W10 and 15 st the staff is very friendly, in order to make a reservation we had to guarantee it with a credit card and were warned of penalties of 50 pp. in case of cancellations. We ordered the tasting menu which consists of 7 dishes including 2 desserts. Food was well prepared and great tasting, caviar, scallops, turbot, squab, wagyu and 2 great desserts, the only problem is that it took too long in some cases the wait was of over 20 minutes between dishes, (our reservation was at 9 and we left at midnight) by the time the main dishes started to arrive we weren't hungry anymore, staff was very friendly and nice but could be more attentive as to clearing glasses and making sure the table was impeccable and perhaps explaining why it was taking longer than expected. The bill was about 700 for a family of four with no wine and a couple of cocktails. I'm sure it doesn't happen often, but this details shouldn't get overlooked by the management.
If you own or manage Colicchio & Sons, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.