Visited with my husband and my father recently and it was really exceptional. We live in the neighborhood so we have eaten here a bit (my husband for work - me with friends/family). They give you a ton of amuses so you feel like you are getting a tasting menu - even when you are dining a la carte. Staff is on par w/ any of the best restaurants in the city. Nothing but good things to say.
If you own or manage Colicchio & Sons, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.