This is a beautiful restauarnt with great service. We started out with some complimentary bread, hot and fresh straight from the oven. We ordered a small pizza for entree to share - fresh ingredients, perfect pizza dough.
Unfortunately our main course "Roasted Chicken with seasonal vegetables" for two was a let down. I have had some amazing, juicy, succulent chickens before but unfortunately this was average at best. The seasonal vegetables were also quite just OK. The waiter asked how everything was and I replied with "it's good thanks, not amazing to be honest, but still good" he left and returned later to apologize and say that the main course was going to be taken off the bill - wow what great service - all I said was that it was good but not amazing, so was quite impressed with this.
The mains coming out at other tables looked great so definitely recommend giving this place a try - just skip the chicken for two option.
If you own or manage Colicchio and Sons Main Dining Room, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.