We went to Frankie and Johnnie's on 45th St. with high expectations. Place was small and empty had absolutely no atmosphere. We picked the 45th St. location because it was originally John Barrymore's town home so we thought...wow...lots of atmosphere...NONE AT ALL. Steaks, once we received what we originally ordered were great BUT two of our $50.00 steaks were ordered medium rare and both came out medium. For an establishment of this nature a steak should never come out cooked wrong, not to mention two of them! We ordered 3 sides ($10.00 each), 2 veggies and 1 mushroom. We imagined putting some great sauteed mushrooms over our steaks...WRONG. Veggies and mushrooms where all boiled with no seasoning whatsoever (including the mushrooms which were whole mushroom caps). Bread was hard as a rock. Our waiter was weird and service was just OK....barely an apology for their error in cooking nor for the 2 people having to wait an additional 15 mins for their food while the others were eating. We actually think he was eating the steaks we sent back as we were leaving! HORRIBLE PLACE and big waste of $$$. DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY GO ELSEWHERE!!! Any place other than this!
If you own or manage Frankie and Johnnie's Steakhouse, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.