Very nice meal, excellent service. The steaks were cooked perfectly and the complimentary appetisers and desert were a lovely touch. The music was great (classic old stuff) and at the perfect volume so you could still talk to your table, but not hear the next tables conversation.
My only small criticism was the sauces were a bit bland. The pepper sauce wasn't peppery at all and the mushroom sauce was also bland. Most steak restaurants back home (Australia) also offer a rang of mustards and I really missed having a good spicy English mustard on hand. Not sure if that is the done thing here in NYC though, so I can't judge them on this.
Great wine list with reasonably priced bottles all the way up to high end stuff. Overall, very nice place and worth the good reviews
If you own or manage Club A Steakhouse, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.