When I stayed, most other hotels nearby were booked so I was happy to find a hotel for around $250 a night. I stay in NYC almost every month so I know it can be hard to find a good hotel for that price and I wasn't expecting too much. I had read previous reviews talking about a strong smell but they were from June/July so I figured by August the smell would be gone! The room was basic and clean and actually quite spacious by NY standards. I think the ceilings are higher than normal too. No flat screen tv, just a regular one, but I don't come to NY to watch TV!
The main problem was that the room smelled like it was freshly painted. It was STRONG! On top of that there were flies in the room (presumably because they had the window open to air it out but the screen had a hole in it so flies came in). I have almost no sense of smell so it didn't bother me that much, but my friend is very sensitive to things like that and kept having to go downstairs every hour or so to "air out." We asked down at the desk and the woman there said it hadn't been painted recently. Later, after a shift change, we asked the guy at the desk and he said it HAD been painted. He said we could switch rooms the next night but would have to switch back for the night after that - not worth the hassle so we stayed put, left the window open (with a magazine covering the hole).
What sucks is that the Chelsea Savoy could be an awesome hotel (instead of just average) with just a little more attention to detail. It's in a great location (just doors down from the famous Chelsea Hotel) and it's within walking distance of tons of restaurants. I would stay there again. It's a good value for the money (just watch out for the paint smell). Hopefully, it will be aired out by the time you have to stay there!






