The short of it: Rooms are clean, beds are very comfy, the hotel and restaurant is very hip, the way they do customer service and customer experience is exactly the way it is supposed to be done.
I stay here on week long visits for business. The customer service/experience, and obviously comfy bed, is the biggest thing for me when dealing with hotels. The Pearl Hotel has excellent customer service and they actually care about providing a great experience. Everyone is friendly, seem like they enjoy what they are doing and do their jobs well. They hustle to do the right thing.
If you are super picky about noise levels, you should know that on movie night, it doesn't get quiet until about 11 or so. I suggest enjoying the night in the restaurant and being part of the scene. Additionally parking can be tricky on movie night cause it's popular.