My wife and I went on side trip on our way to her parents' wedding anniversary party in NJ. The Angler's inn was pleasant, in a good location, the breakfast excellent, and the hostess was very efficient and congenial.
Our room was on the street side with the "private" bath being across the hall. We did experience some street noise after we had gone to bed. If I stayed there again, I would ask about which rooms were available and try to get one of the rooms not on the street side of the house and with the bath connecting directly to the room. However, I enjoyed our one night stay and thought it was a good value.