We shared three pies at the Noe Valley location, had two drinks, and I can honestly say this was probably the best $12 dinner for two we've ever had in the US. Two of the pies were vegetarian - one with lentils, one primarily with seasoned potatoes - and one meat (for my husband). Three were perfect for two adults - didn't need more - although there certainly is enough variety that more were possible. The seating area was small but clean; most of their business seems to be take-out. They close at 7:00, so it can't be a late dinner, but I would most certainly go back.
If you own or manage Peasant Pies, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.